Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions Soundly Rejected at Davis Food Coop
The Coop Board has voted unanimously to declare a resolution proposing a boycott of Israeli products "improper." This action means that the proposed resolution will not be placed on the Spring ballot for a member vote.
The Board of the Davis Food Co-op has voted unanimously (3/15) to
declare a resolution proposing a boycott of Israeli products
“improper.” This action, coupled with a previous declaration by the
Board declaring the same resolution “unlawful” means that the proposed
resolution will not be placed on the Spring ballot at the Co-op. The
Board’s action was a dramatic rejection of the arguments presented by
the Boycott, Divest, Sanction group that had demanded its resolution be
voted on by the membership of the 10,000-person Co-op. In a broad and
powerful statement, the Board listed numerous reasons that the proposed
boycott resolution was improper among which are: * The initiative has
produced a “tense and uneasy atmosphere at the Co-op, a reduction in
shoppers and sales, disruption to business operations”—which may result
in the permanent loss of whole groups of Co-op shoppers. * The
initiative would demand that the Co-op “accept the Global Boycott,
Divestment and Sanctions for Palestine (BDS) Campaign's
characterization and judgment of Israeli actions as fact”, and require
the Co-op to “accept the Global BDS Campaign's tactics as our own”,
thereby allowing Global BDS to determine the Co-op’s compliance with
its principles and policies. In essence, the Board said that it would
be forced to turn over the Co-op’s “management and operation” to a
political movement whose objective has nothing to do the continued
viability of the Co-op. * The initiative runs counter to the Rochdale
Principles, upon which the cooperative movement was founded.
Specifically, the initiative violates the basic principle of political
and religious neutrality and the idea that cooperatives should avoid
the dangers of meddling in political and religious affairs. * The
initiative demands the Co-op make a judgment about the legitimacy or
illegitimacy of actions or policies of the Israeli government,
particularly with respect to extraordinary actions taken by such
government that have been invoked in the name of its national
security—a judgment the Co-op Board feels unqualified to make. The
Board’s declaration comes at the end of a three month period during
which the BDS proponents staged community events and tabled regularly
at the Co-op to further their proposed resolution. These efforts were
opposed by a broad coalition of community residents and community
groups such as Congregation Bet Haverim, The Interfaith Coalition for
Peace and Justice in the Middle East, and the Jewish Community
Relations Council of Sacramento. The action of the Davis Food Co-op
Board is just the latest in a series of actions taken by groups around
the United States that resoundingly express disagreement with the goals
and positions of the BDS movement.